May 28 Podcast #427: brite-View Air HD Review
A few weeks ago water damage in Braden's home forced him to remove the ceiling in his family room. He took advantage of this "opportunity" to run some new cables to allow for the installation of a front projector. Of course, one of the necessary cables in that endeavor was HDMI. But not everyone wants to rip out their ceiling to run HDMI.
Listen to the show
Today's Show:
News:
- Samung previews 19" transparent AMOLED panel
- Canon to freeze development of home-use SED TVs
- TiVo and Best Buy Developing Connected Television
- DirecTV rolls out 3D upgrade for newer set-tops, older ones left in the cold
Other:
- SIG Insurance Professionals - We shop for insurance so you don't have to, and how to insure your home theater.
- Sarah's site for Susan G. Komen's 3-Day for the Cure
- Speaker City in Burbank, CA - Custom Home Theater installation and whole house audio/video integration since 1977.
- Robert Flutie For Congress in California District 30 (listener supported, not an HT Guys endorsement)
brite-View Air HD Review
A few weeks ago water damage in Braden's home forced him to remove the ceiling in his family room. He took advantage of this "opportunity" to run some new cables to allow for the installation of a front projector. Of course, one of the necessary cables in that endeavor was HDMI. But not everyone wants to rip out their ceiling to run HDMI.
Even with the ceiling torn out, it was a challenge to get the cables run through all the joists and studs. Making sure they made it from the right location at the source to the correct location for the projector was quite an ordeal. A wireless solution would have been easier for sure. We have been talking about the promise of wireless HD for a while, but it hasn't quite materialized yet.
Looking around, however, you may come across the brite-View Air HD. The first thing you'll notice is that prices are dropping. It has an MSRP of $399 US, but it is on sale right now for only $279.99. The last wireless HD solution we tried, the Gefen Wireless HDMI Adapter, was selling for $999 at the time. We had decent success with the Gefen unit, but our hopes were high for the brite-View.
Setup
Setting up the Air HD is trivial. You plug your source equipment into the transmitter, plug your display device in the receiver, and you're done. The two units find each other automatically, link up and work with minimal intervention. You can transmit IR over the same link using the included IR sensor plugged into the receiver and IR blasters plugged into the transmitter.
Specs
According to the brite-View website, the unit supports:
- Uncompressed HD quality audio and video
- Up to 1080i@60Hz & 1080p@24Hz HD picture quality/30Hz HD quality
- Less than 1ms latency for playing video game console
- Long transmission distance: 65 feet with Line of Sight, 32 feet without
- Multiple inputs: 2 HDMI, 2 Component & Composite
Performance
We tested using Blu-ray, HD-DVD and HDTV. With a good signal, the video quality was perfect. We couldn't tell the difference between the HDMI cable and the Air HD. That said, we couldn't get a good signal at 65 feet. At that distance, even with Line of Sight, there was some noise in the picture and some strange audio artifacts.
At first, the picture was pretty rough even at 50 feet, but the Air HD allows you to switch channels in case other equipment in your home is causing interference. After switching the channel we were able to get perfect transmission at around 50 feet with Line of Sight and 27ish feet without. In addition, IR commands were transferred instantly. There was no perceptible delay with button presses.
Value
At $999 a wireless HDMI unit would need to blow you away to make it worth it, but at $279, it enters the realm of possibility for many more of us. A 50 foot HDMI cable will set you back about $15, to upgrade to an in-wall rated cable will cost closer to $30. At that point it really depends on how much wall damage and repair work you have to do to exceed the total $279 cost.
Keep in mind that the Air HD only supports up to 24 frames per second in 1080p. That means it won't allow you to run 1080p/60 from a Blu-ray disc and won't support the 120 fps you'd need to get 3D. If your primary use for the projector is TV, since the ATSC spec only goes up to 1080i/60 and 1080p/30, you won't miss a thing. If you want support for the latest and greatest Blu-ray has to offer, you may want to go with a fixed cable solution, even if it's a bit more expensive and less convenient.
Conclusion
There are so many more uses for the Air HD than just front projectors. It'll work really well for backyard and outdoor theaters. You could use it to stream TV to a room in the house that doesn't have Coax, like a bathroom, workshop or garage. If you have a TV that's constantly moving based on what's happening at home, you'd only ever need to plug it into the wall to get great quality HDTV on it.
At $279 we'll leave it up to your imagination to decide the best use for it, but in our tests it worked really well. We didn't get it to live up exactly to the full advertised specs, but when the signal was solid, the audio and video were solid and it was a cinch to get setup.
Reader Comments (1)
Thanks for the mention!
On wireless HDMI it really never made sense for use with a front projector. In most cases you're up in that area running power anyway so what's another in-wall rated cable while you're doing the pull?
Where this does make sense specifically for me is that I have a 42" Samsung LCD wall mounted in our master bedroom that I have been struggling getting a HDMI cable to. It's an exterior wall, brick outside, and a vaulted ceiling (the trifecto of cabling hell) so I can not access the top plate to drill through the wall. It's the "worst case scenario" as 6 attempts so far to run HDMI cable from the TV up the wall, through the vault, across the ceiling, and into our bedroom closet where I have our media center server has failed. It also doesn't help that Texas attic temps can get 160-180*F. I am pulling power within 4' horizontally but was using a 50' HDMI (length worked while testing) but in reality is probably 30' from TV to source. I'm going to try this out (or the Gefen EXT-WHDMI since it's smaller and sends back IR) and let you know how it works in my setup.